Former Secretary of State Natalie Tennant was born on December 25, 1967, in Fairmont and grew up in nearby Fairview as the youngest of seven children. She attended West Virginia University where she was selected as the first female Mountaineer in 1990. She received her bachelor's degree from WVU in 1991 and master's degree in 2000.

Tennant became well-known throughout the state during the 20 years she worked in television broadcasting in Clarksburg and Charleston. After leaving journalism, she was co-owner of Wells Media Group with her husband, Erik Wells. Wells, also a former journalist, was a West Virginia state senator.

In 2004, Tennant ran for secretary of state but lost in the Democratic primary to Ken Hechler. In 2008, Secretary of State Betty Ireland chose not to seek reelection, and Tennant entered the race. She defeated two legislators, Joe DeLong and Billy Wayne Bailey, in the primary and GOP contender Charles Minimah in the general election.

As secretary of state, Tennant focused on the use of technology. She promoted a program that allowed members of the military and other state residents who are overseas to cast their votes online.

Following the death of Senator Robert Byrd in 2010, Tennant found herself at the center of debates about special elections. Ultimately, Governor Joe Manchin was elected to fill the Senate post. Tennant ran for governor in 2011, but lost in the Democratic primary to Earl Ray Tomblin, who went on to win in the general election. She was reelected as secretary of state on November 6, 2012.

In 2014, Tennant sought the seat held by retiring U.S. Senator Jay Rockefeller, but she was defeated by Republican Shelley Moore Capito. In 2016, she lost her race for reelection to Republican Mac Warner. In the May 2024 primary election, Tennant won the Democratic nomination for an open seat on the Kanawha County Commission and won the general election by less than 400 votes.